RV How-Tos

Aluminum vs Fiberglass Siding

May 7, 2019

One question people always ask me is: “What is the difference between aluminum siding and fiberglass siding on an RV?” This article will teach you some of the advantages, disadvantages, and differences.

The easiest way to tell the difference between aluminum siding and fiberglass siding is that aluminum is usually wavy (but not always). Fiberglass siding is usually smooth.

Fiberglass Siding
Aluminum Siding
Also Aluminum Siding

Aluminum Siding

Aluminum sided campers usually have wood frames in their walls. That’s because the aluminum is stapled to the wood studs. They are also usually insulated with fiberglass insulation. Inside the RV is a panel stapled to the wall that you see on the interior of the camper.

Advantages

  • Usually aluminum campers are much less expensive. An aluminum sided camper can be thousands less expensive than its fiberglass twin. If you have an accident, with an aluminum sided camper, you may be able replace the one or two damaged panels by yourself.
  • The exterior walls on an aluminum sided camper are hollow. This means running cables and wires is much easier.
  • Wood framing does not transfer heat and cold through the wall as quickly as aluminum framing.
  • Tried and true. It has been around for MANY years an it is not going anywhere.

Disadvantages

  • Water damage if you do not properly inspect the silicone on the side or roof corners of your camper and you develop a leak.
    • Water will run down the inside of the wall and can then rot your walls and floor. It can take many months before the leak is discovered causing significant damage and a costly repair.
  • In older aluminum sided campers, the batt insulation could fall down inside the wall leaving an air gap at the top of the wall. This means that the camper may not hold temperature as well (you will lose heat quickly in colder temperature).  Newer campers do glue the insulation in place on each side of the batt insulation. However there still could be insulation gaps.
  • Hail damages aluminum siding pretty quickly. However, insurance may cover it.

Fiberglass Siding

Fiberglass is attached to either Lauan wood or in some newer campers Azdale. Azdale is a woven fiberglass / plastic product that does not absorb water. The siding is glued to the aluminum frame and foam block insulation. The interior paneling is then glued to the inside of the foam block insulation.

Example of a Fiberglass Wall

Advantages

  • If you do not properly inspect your silicone and you develop a leak.
    • Water can infiltrate your walls but will not run down to the floor and rot your floor due to the foam block insulation and glue.
  • Fiberglass walls are generally quieter. Keeping sound out or in.
  • There is often less flex in fiberglass walls.
  • There are not staples on the exterior walls.
  • Better looking walls with less putty usage.
  • There are no wires ran in exterior walls, the walls are solid.
  • Usually easier to clean.
  • Hail does not damage fiberglass like aluminum.
    • Fiberglass is generally a little more durable to hits or dents.
  • Fiberglass does tend to look better a little longer and hold its resale value.
  • Campers that have the fiberglass affixed to Azdale may not experience as much fiberglass de-lamination.
    • Azdale does not absorb water.  Adale has only been around a limited number of years and a lot of manufacturers do not use it due to its price.

Disadvantages

  • If water gets inside the walls due to an exterior leak de-lamination of the fiberglass can occur.
    • This is a very real problem in older RVs. If considering buying a fiberglass RV or camper inspect it very closely for waves, bubbles or flaws. A lot of fiberglass walls have this problem. The buyer also needs to inspect the inside walls especially near the corners and under windows. Because the water cannot run down the inside of the wall it may run down the outside of the wall causing the paneling to peel. De-lamination often occurs from water penetrating the wall however could be just as simple as the glue let loose between the fiberglass and the Lauan wood. De-lamination is very expensive to repair, sometimes the entire wall needs to be replaced.
  • The RV owner cannot run wires through the walls making satellite cables difficult to run.
  • If something strikes the the fiberglass wall. Spiderweb like cracks can occur, being very expensive to repair.
    • Fiberglass is much more expensive to fix if in an accident.  The typical RVer cannot repair this themselves.
    • When a tree branch is drug along the side of a fiberglass sided RV it’s very easy to notice the scrape marks.
  • The rear and front walls of a fiberglass RV are not vacuum bonded or pinch rolled and glued. This allows for camper flexibility. In the case of the camper below there was a very thin layer of fiberglass which was glued to cardboard and then attached to the wood frame walls only by  the edges, the window pinching it and the ladder being attached to the back end. Once that cardboard became wet the wall look terrible. The entire back wall needed to be rebuilt.
De-Lamination

Conclusion

Fiberglass wins hands-down in durability, shine and cleanliness. However aluminum sided campers have been, and will be, around forever. In my opinion it’s a matter of what the buyer prefers. This is especially true if cost is not an issue.

Some people believe aluminum sided Campers are lighter then fiberglass sided campers this is not usually true. The aluminum is stapled to wood which is fairly heavy. Fiberglass sided campers are generally glued to aluminum framing and solid foam insulation. The weight difference between aluminum sided and fiberglass sided trailers is minimal.

Some people also believe aluminum is not as aerodynamic as fiberglass and fiberglass sided campers will get better gas mileage. I don’t believe there’s a big enough difference to make that a factor when and considering purchasing your next RV.

On a side note. Do not use a pressure washer to wash your camper unless you’re keeping it far back from the camper. Using a pressure washer can drive water beneath your Silicone and remove your decals. I recommend blue Dawn dish soap and a soft brush. For tough stains use black streak remover or bug remover.

Hopefully now you are at least a little more educated on fiberglass vs aluminum sided campers. As with most things regarding an RV it is really up the the buyer and what they prefer.

Happy Camping!

You May Also Like

Pre-Delivery Inspections

March 18, 2019

What is a monitor system? How does that work?

February 11, 2019

How to Stop the Beeping in your Camper!

November 19, 2018

27 Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Facebook
Facebook
Instagram
Twitter
Pinterest